When polarisation pays: what if being disliked is good for business?

When polarisation pays: what if being disliked is good for business?

As brands compete to provoke a reaction, is being liked becoming less important than being impossible to ignore?

From Jaguar’s radical reinvention to Sydney Sweeney’s partnership with Novig, PHA Group's Mike Chivers explores provocation as a commercial choice: pushing a brand so far that its next big move feels normal or embracing a divisive personality because fans and critics both keep it in circulation. 

The question running through both is: when does polarisation build desire, and when are we simply mistaking attention for influence?

Has being disliked become a marketing strategy?

Most creative briefs ask for some version of the same thing: make people like us. More relevant. More relatable. More loved. Famous. But fame and affection aren’t the same objective.

A clever idea can stop the scroll.

An argument can keep a brand in circulation long after the original impression. Fans defend it. Critics dissect it. Everyone gives someone else a reason to look. For some brands, disapproval seems an acceptable cost.

Jaguar’s reinvention and Sydney Sweeney’s partnership with sports prediction platform Novig, though radically different, do raise the same question: is being liked becoming less important than being impossible to ignore? 

Perhaps, but being disliked isn’t much of a strategy. Knowing whose approval you can afford to lose is.

Make the unfamiliar feel inevitable

Jaguar’s 2024 reinvention pushed almost every available lever: identity, casting, colour, language and the Type 00 concept, unveiled in Miami Pink and London Blue. The debate quickly became about whether this could still be Jaguar. Critics saw an abandonment of its heritage. Others saw a necessary break from a brand that had lost its commercial footing.

The creative itself became the story. The Verge called the rebranding “bizarre”. Elon Musk’s response to the launch film was more economical: “Do you sell cars?” But beyond the backlash lies an interesting possibility: an extreme first impression can change how we judge everything that follows.

The silver Type 01 arrives in a world the pink concept has already disrupted. Its proportions remain extraordinary. Our reference point has changed. And some reactions suggest the unfamiliar is becoming easier to accept.

The rebrand “finally makes sense”, declared one review. Another described “a much better balance of freshness and consistency”. A third put it plainly: “having now seen the final production version, I completely get what the Jaguar Type 01 stands for”.

These reviews don’t establish a universal change of heart or prove that shock followed by acceptance was the plan. But they suggest that provocative creative can shift expectations before the product has to meet them. 

Push expectations far enough, and a radical reinvention can start to feel reasonable. 

The commercial test remains that 'less shocking' is only useful if it becomes more desirable.

When criticism becomes distribution

Novig’s approach to criticism is more explicit. Its “Just Sports” campaign features Sweeney appearing nude, strategically covered by sporting equipment. The product message is straightforward: make sports predictions rather than markets on politics, wars or death.

The execution ensures people look. Whether the product message lands is another question.

Sweeney wasn’t simply a celebrity hired to deliver it. She is an equity holder and, according to CEO Jacob Fortinsky, drove much of the campaign’s visual direction and messaging.

Novig also anticipated opposition. Fortinsky told Front Office Sports: “We obviously expected the people who already hate her would be loud and vocal”. That is a clearer account of the calculation than any retrospective claim that all publicity is good publicity.

Athletes posted competition footage declaring “this is what a woman in sports looks like”, challenging the campaign’s sexualisation of women around sport. 

Sweeney countered by sharing nude athlete portraits from ESPN’s Body Issue, suggesting nudity needn’t undermine sporting credibility. But an athlete revealing their body and an actor using sports equipment to sell a prediction platform are different propositions. The disagreement kept the campaign moving.

Critics became distributors without becoming endorsers. Supporters had something to defend. 

Novig had more opportunities to explain what it sells. And the activity went beyond views. Novig reported trading volume up nearly 94% and first-time depositors up more than 218% in the 20 days after launch, compared with the preceding 20.

However, those are company-reported figures, coinciding with the start of the NFL season. They don’t tell us how much growth came from the campaign, let alone the controversy. But dismissing it as empty noise is too easy. The harder question is whether the attention brought customers who will stay.

The backlash becomes a brief

Provocation can create a platform for someone else. The reaction to Novig exposed a tension around how women are represented in sport. Powerade answered with 'Never Just Sports': women swimming, playing tennis and competing in athletics, with achievement taking centre stage. 

One added word turned a controversial campaign into an opportunity to say something meaningful about sport.

That is the wider creative opportunity. Backlash reveals what people feel strongly about. 

A brand that listens can turn that feeling into work people want to support. Novig could gain customers while Powerade could build affinity. Both could benefit. But the brand that buys the attention doesn’t necessarily own what it becomes. Someone else’s controversy can become your brief.

Being disliked isn’t the point

Jaguar raises the possibility that provocation can make radical change easier to accept. Novig shows how criticism can keep a campaign moving. Powerade shows that the response can become an opportunity in itself.

The question is less whether brands can afford to be disliked, and more what they gain by risking it. A new audience? A shift in expectations? A stronger reason to choose them?

If the only answer is “people are talking”, the strategy is unfinished.

If you enjoyed this article, you can subscribe for free to our weekly email alert and receive a regular curation of the best creative campaigns by creatives themselves.

Published on: